Cynefin, Weather, Stone - Design is enabled by constraint

A garden can not escape its place.The geography, geology and climate  are givens. Even if (as we shall see later) you cheat the place - you are only cheating because of the place and the gardener's understanding of the place. This blog post is by way of some detail so that you can understand the rest of the story that follows.

Design is enabled by constraint. This may sound contrary. However the imagination is often triggered by overcoming problems, providing for what HAS to be done and the inner glow of finding a neat solution.  I am willing to make some mistakes in this process- trying things that may be on-the-edge of possible(as long as my pocket can take it). This is part of the cynefin process.

Climate and Location
Bronceris, in the village of Menai Bridge,  is on a spur, with an elevation of 40m above sea level.  The sea, albeit a 150m strait, is only 300m away. The ground slopes downward on three sides.The larger part of the garden is due South of the house - a southern slope.   The bottom of the garden is about 5m below  the house. There is a slight slope from West to East. There are, as I will show, some points of man-made alterations at geology’s changes of level - constructed for horticultural and aesthetic interest.  Thus although the garden is downhill - much of it is seems quite flat.

Bronceris is 53°N  - which coupled  with its maritime location means  a cool temperate garden-  Zone 9 - which allows a lot of plants to grow outside that can not survive elsewhere in the UK. Rainfall is a satisfactory 1020-1050mm a year. We have mild wet winters - with only a few nights below  0°,  and mild wet summers with only a few days above 25°. It is windy though. The prevailing wind is from  the wet  southwest  - gusts of 80kph are not uncommon - but the worst is when we get winter winds from the  east which are dry, depressing and sometimes destructive.

Geology and  Soil
The geological map of Anglesey is like a 1960‘s psychedelic poster.   Bron Ceris is at a point where two types of bedrock border.  Both are very old, pre-cambrian  rock. These are named Gwna, and the rock that is found in the garden-  Anglesey Blue Schist. Anglesey blue schists are rocks that include metabasites containing a metamorphic mineral assemblage that shows that they have been subjected to unusually high pressures, such as those found deep within a subduction zone.” (GeoMon).  In practice schist boulders are brittle, shapeless, and hard to form into useful bits of stone - far from the ideal garden stone.  Therefore, as you will find, I have had to introduce some alien stones into the garden for a variety of purposes.  However Schist is what I have - and it is very, very close to the surface - with many natural outcrops around the property. 
Consequently the soil is  very stony. We have a good organic layer - which I intend to sustain with annual mulching, and in most places another 200-300mm of good topsoils  leading to a very variable depth of subsoil (0-500mm) before hitting bedrock.  The soil is the acid side on neutral.

The geology provides wonderful opportunity and constraint.  The garden is bound by its place. You dig and you find stones. The garden’s beds are raised and edged by this native stone. it doesn’t make for clean lines and straight edges -an inescapable factor in the design.

Making a garden; Cynefin, Design, Emergence

Design, at best, is an emergent process - and essentially so when it is about gardens.  As much as designed gardens at events like the Chelsea Flower Show are inspiring and lovely to look at, they are snapshots for the week of the show. Deterministic design  works for a fleeting moment.  Making a real garden is a rich practice of design. It is at the end of the  year that I have spent on a new stage of putting out probing designs on Bron Ceris’s  garden. The coming seasons will reveal what works and what  will  be changed:  a process of reflection that will come sitting in the garden or weeding a flower bed - and in narrating stories in this blog.

Cynefin is a Welsh word that does not easily translate. it is often translated as habitat - but that is only a beginning. It has the same notion that sheep farmers have of hefted:  a flock of sheep that know their bit of mountain that is passed down from the ewe to her lambs. In Welsh it carries more meaning. In humans it carries with it a sense of place, home-ness, of shared cultural knowledge,  a belonging. Cynefin has also been used by Dave Snowden to describe approaches to managing complexity. Within this framework there is a description for working with the complex -  a situation  which is new, where causes and effects are expected but are as yet unknown. This describes the situation when you are making garden. Will the plant like the spot? Will it work with its neighbours?  What extra interventions will be needed to sustain and keep it viable? Does it fit  with the life habits of those for whom the garden is home (wild and domestic)? 

Cynefin suggests a way to deal with the complex.   You need to perform safe-to-fail experiments. Take many readings/reflections of the consequences  and then amplify the successes and attenuate the failures.  This is  the approach I am taking in Bron Ceris. 

As with all design I work with known constraints and opportunities - which will be described as we blog further.  And as with all design - we will be working towards the desirable.  However that begs the question “what is desirable in this context?”  It has to satisfy the requirements of Sue and I,  it has to fulfill my creative needs, it needs to continue to be fun and challenging,  it has to live within a budget, allow us to go on holidays  and balance carefully the joy of gardening with  the chores of gardening.  Low maintenance gardens are for the surrounds of office buildings, roundabouts and public conveniences - gardening is part of the pleasure.   I want to create wow-factors, I also want to create space  which is out-of-time - a chance for garden mindfulness.



In some ways the garden is not Cynefin.  Is there such a thing as a traditional Welsh garden?  I don’t think so. Bron Ceris  is a garden full of the exotic.  On the other hand, there is a phrase I am trying to understand:  wabi sabi.  A phrase Wikipedia tells me  that “The aesthetic is sometimes described as one of beauty that is imperfect, impermanent, and incomplete".   But I suspect it is a bit like trying to translate Cynefin.









Digging up the Iris

Yesterday I dug out the bearded Iris in the top terrace centre bed. They had been there since the bed was created about 4 years ago.They produced about 5 flowers in that time,took up a lot of ground and the leaves were torn, windswept and  fundamentally manky.  They did not deserve the garden space devoted to them. I can not think where I might place them. Currently they languish, loosely potted.


What to put in their place?  The bed is the sunniest spot in the garden.The rest of the planting in the bed is:

  • 8 or so marmalade coloured dahlia's : Dahlia 'Mel's Orange Marmalade', Dahlia 'Alfred Grille', and Dahlia 'David Howard'
  • Tangerine coloured Papever rupifragrum
  • a variety of begonias which I do not dig up and are going from strength to strength year on year
  • apricot and brown Phormium
  • Watsonia "tresco hybrids"
  • newly planted Gerbera gravenia in yellow and orange (honey glow and  sweet glow)
  • and the odd nasturtium(various)

It is very much a hot bed in the sunniest spot in the garden.  This year I will  go with the flow because in my stock of plants to go out I have six Geum  "Mrs Bradshaw"  and some seed  grown Dahlia "Bishop's Children" - the one's that have flowered thus far are a deep red.

In spring I have tulips in pots nearby - but I think I will buy some big Aliums to replace the interest I was expecting from the Iris in May- June. Here it is now.

I shall report on progress throughout the season.



Crops 7 Sept 2013

Nature's Bounty today included:

Salad Bowl lettuce Figs (brown turkey) -which I meant to photograph but they were eaten with Parma Ham and the lettuce - totally delicious. Basil - as apart of a mango, chilli and basil salsa Runner Beans

and I harvested the main crop potatoes : Sarpo Mira - which were sampled as sauté.

Mira are a variety of potato developed the research team in Henfaes in Bangor to be blight resistant. In first inspection it seems they would make very good chips and roast spuds. I will photograph them in a future post. They have ranged from new potato size to a good half-kilo per spud. Yield very satisfactory - taste was good. Maybe tomorrow the "mash" test.

The new garden blog

A lot has happened in the garden since the demise of Posterous.  Over the next few months I will post on what will be current developments and there will be some catch up posts.  

The main developments have been:

  • Development of a kitchen garden
  • Construction of a glasshouse - mainly for propagating and overwintering of tender plants
  • the second season of the exotic beds - with more plants
  • the loss of 66% of the lawn - waiting to be planted
  • The building of a level change wall - creating a defined area for Japanese style garden leading to woodland garden
  • Clearance of the last 20m of garden (except for the remaining trees and shrubs) in anticipation of woodland garden
  • Creating slate-chipping paths around the garden

When I see as this list I realise how much work has been done - and moreover how much fun is going to be had now that most of the hard landscape work is over. The previous 2 years were mainly about slate paving on the terraces and the recreation of the terrace beds close to the house. From now on it is mostly about the plants.

Currently there are eight areas of distinct planting:

  • A terrace close to the house which is mainly about exotic/hot planting ( the terrace faces due south)
  • A trad mixed border on the eastern boundary
  • A rose garden at the southern/eastern side of the garden
  • A kitchen garden around a detached garage to the east of the house
  • A prairie style bed on the western boundary
  • A large shady area on the southern perimeter to become a woodland garden
  • An area with my attempt at a Japanese sensibility
  • A gravel area with Mediterranean plants

And there is a small wildlife pond. Some of this is going to change over the next few years - especially as I have removed most of the lawn.

Sue looks after the beds at the front of the house.

Over the next month the paths will be completed and I will concentrate on the Japanese area.